Skip to main content

Teaching as an Embodied Practice


"Recognition is inextricably intertwined with selfhood and personal identity"

"the practical active knowledge that animates teaching is something that belongs phenomenologically more closely to the whole embodied being of the person as well as to the social and physical world in which this person lives"

"our actions are sedimented into habituations, routines, kinesthetic memories ... [and] are sensitive to the contigencies, novelties and expectancies of our world."

I'd like to unpack these quotations with reference to the Heideggerian term Befindlichkeit that Manen mentions and to the Greek term phronesis that he alludes to when talking about 'practical wisdom.'

Central to both of these concepts is the idea of situatedness/embodiment/being-in-the-world. For Manen, and for me, this idea of temporal, spatial and individual existence is the critical piece, oft underemphasized by students, of teaching education. It reminds me of the three-body problem in computational modeling. Given two bodies, we can enter all we know about them and a computer can easily output a model of how those two bodies will interact. Add a third body, however, and the computer can no longer handle the load of variability needed to accurately make a predictive model. This is a good analogy for the experience of teaching. No amount of knowledge in the world can prepare us for the reality of teaching in a classroom full of students, each with their own experiential pasts, bodies, and brains. Even if there were only one student for each teacher, there are simply too many variables to consider. This is why I love the way Manen emphasizes the in-between place where theoretical, intellectual knowledge meets the physical reality of existence. It's the bridge between higher-level problem solving and baser instinct; it's where the rational and the animal interact.

To my mind, there is no way to develop and strengthen these interactions other than to practice.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Being Welcome (For Oct. 12 in-class)

Below are some common classroom experiences that make me feel more or less welcome: Positive experiences opportunities to self-determine my learning space to give and to revoke consent individual attention recognition of difference between students (race, sexuality, gender, interest, etc.) teacher openness regarding and willingness to correct mistakes acceptance and praise of student mistakes as part of the learning process deliberate and explicit class and subject expectations space for and acceptance of the need for physicality and movement space and flexibility for questions and "off-topic" moments organization and routine respect for personal boundaries teacher investment in my learning positive interdependence and personal investment in my learning Negative experiences presumptive and gendered language (the scientist = he; the nurse = she) cis-hetero-normative assumptions (binary pronouns used without checking, assuming that someone who "loo...
Post a Comment
Read more

Controlled Confusion?

Controlled confusion . Is this an oxymoron? Educational neuroscience reminds us that excess stress - when all you see on the board is hieroglyphs or the white hot panic when Teacher asks you a question and you're not even sure it was in English - gets in the way of learning. And not just a little. Chronic experience of excess stress will actually re-wire the brain in such a way that it can no longer properly regulate emotion. Imagine trying to concentrate when your body is in a constant state of fight, flight or freeze . It's obvious, then, that confusion has no place in the classroom. But is it? One of the tensions expressed in educational neuroscience and effective learning is that there is an optimal level of stress. Too much gets in the way, but too little does also. Learning is hard, and in order to make the cognitive jump to higher understanding, we need a little oomph. Healthy stress is an incredibly useful motivator. In this way, Teacher must balance on one scale  a ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Riding a Unicycle on a Sailboat in a Storm?

"You have to go where adolescents are" - Frank McCourt The more I learn about teaching the more I realize that it is a constantly shifting balancing act. Am I professional enough but not too distant? Am I engaging my students but also teaching the required curriculum? Am I honouring teenage experiences but not overstepping on parents' rights? For Frank McCourt, erring on the side of adolescent realities was a key component of his practice of Teacher Inquiry and Teaching by Inquiry. Being true to his students informed not only the way he comported himself and interacted with his students, but also they actual material and lessons he taught. By being personal and personalizing his class material, McCourt engaged his students in an honest and meaningful way. I intend for student realities to inform my own practice, but the extent to which this will be possible is very dependent on school context. I admire McCourt's dedication to honesty, but wonder how much presen...
Post a Comment
Read more